ROTHSTEIN William A. Rothstein, 60, longtime Summit Township resident, Friday July 30, 2004. The FBI found bomb-making materials in Rothsteins home. Bombmaking materials were found in Rothstein's home. The device consisted of two parts: a triple-banded metal collar with four keyholes and a three-digit combination lock, and an iron box containing two 6-inch pipe bombs loaded with double-base smokeless powder. A retired FBI criminal investigator, Fisher started closely tracking the collar bomb case after he saw footage of Wells squirming on the pavement with the device yoked around his neck. She is buried in the Gibson Family plot at LaGrange Cemetery. Rothstein claimed to have been hired by Diehl-Armstrong to dispose of the body of her boyfriend for the past ten years, James Roden. The FBI believes a Stockton associate, William Rothstein, was the mastermind of the heist and likely made the bomb, the affidavit says. When Diehl-Armstrong met with federal investigators for a series of interviews, that's exactly what she appeared to be doing. The team of federal agents investigating the collar bomb mystery hadn't been paying much attention to the Roden murder. By entering your email and clicking Sign Up, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. The picture expresses the tension of Act III of The Doll's House when Mrs Linden and Krogstad are listening for the end of the dance upstairs. It was too late. After he telephoned police, Rothstein wrote a suicide note indicating his planned death had nothing to do with Wells. [8] Rothenstein's role as artistic manager of the gallery was abandoned in 1901, whereupon the firm came under the management of his close friend Robert Ross. Now comes the chilling coincidence; Bill Rothstein's house, with Roden's body in the garage, is located exactly next to the dirt road leading to the specific tower site that Brian Wells was sent to deliver the pizzas on August 28, 2003. [1] Men and Memories Volume I includes anecdotes about Oscar Wilde and many other friends of Rothenstein's, including Max Beerbohm, James Whistler, Paul Verlaine, Edgar Degas, and John Singer Sargent. WebSir William Rothenstein The Dolls House 18991900 Image released under Creative Commons CC-BY-NC-ND (3.0 Unported) License this image In Tate Britain Walk Through British Art: 1890 Free Artist Sir William Rothenstein 18721945 Medium Oil paint on canvas Dimensions Support: 889 610 mm frame: 1092 819 74 mm Collection Tate Acquisition This post was published on the now-closed HuffPost Contributor platform. Brian Wells is not the pizza bomber; he is a murder victim. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Cond Nast. And so was Rothstein, the man who turned her in for Roden's murder. Son of the late Matthias and B. Virginia Bryner Rothstein. His backyard extended almost to the transmission tower. Rothstein's suicide note, it seemed, was a lie; Diehl-Armstrong had said that Roden's murder had everything to do with the collar bomb plot. And Wells, the purported victim, was another. More than two hundred of Rothenstein's portraits of famous people can be found in the National Portrait Gallery collection. WebOn September 20, 2003, Rothstein, who lived near the television tower, called police to inform them the body of a man, James Roden, was hidden in a freezer in a garage at his house. The White House 1600 Pennsylvania Ave NW Washington, DC 20500 To William W. Popp, Nominee for Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary to the Republic of Uganda The riddles transfixed the city of Erie and drew headlines in newspapers from St. Louis to Sydney. Your culture and entertainment cheat-sheet. Then he sat in the witness box and matter-of-factly described the conspiracy to a rapt jury. Wells drove straight there after he left the bank with the bag of cash. While he initially came into the investigation as a neighbor and former lover of Diehl-Armstrong, his involvement went much deeper, making us wonder, who is Bill Rothstein? The jury didn't buy it. She feeds liver to her cats and dogs.". Powered by obsessed film buffs, its a crowdsourced juggernaut thats older than Google and Wikipedia. WILLIAM ROTHSTEIN OBITUARY. It looked like he was trying to scoot backward, to somehow escape the bomb strapped to his neck. ", says an old friend. from Peggy in FL February 28, 2018 for William C. House, MD. Who Is Bill Rothstein? Most of Rothenstein's interiors feature members of his family, especially his wife Alice. It was 3:18 pm. Which lets you explain your symptoms before he hive you his opinion. He died a free man. Pulling together information culled from more than a thousand interviews over almost four years, the indictment charged that Wells was in on the scheme from the beginning. In September, almost one month after the death of Brian Wells, Rothstein called 911, telling the dispatcher, At 8645 Peach Street, in the garage, there is a frozen body. Interestingly, Diehl-Armstrong put the FBI onto Barnes in the first place. The device also contained two Sunbeam kitchen timers and one electronic countdown timer. TV camera crews arrived and began filming. Wells fidgeted. RELATED:Haunting True Stories & Important Lessons From 9 People Who SURVIVED Attempted Murder. [8] During its early years the gallery was closely associated with artists Charles Conder, Philip Wilson Steer, Charles Ricketts and Augustus John. For those who closely tracked the case, the government's long-awaited announcement was severely unsatisfying. I enjoy spending time with my boyfriend, dog, family, and co-workers. The proximity of Roden's body, Rothstein's house and the TV tower site where Brian Wells was sent to deliver the pizzas was no coincidence. p.49. Then he lifted his shirt to reveal a heavy, boxlike device dangling from his neck. We would like to hear from you. In Fisher's view, Rothstein toyed with the investigators from the start, concocting the scavenger hunt at least in part to send them on a useless chase, eating up valuable time in the precious days after the robbery. A tiny Scottish village is betting its future on rocket launches. Wells asked a trooper at one point, apparently concerned that his employer would think he was shirking his duties. But he turned out to be hiding a dark secret. He was knighted in 1931 for his services to art. The man identified himself as Bill Rothstein. After he telephoned police, Rothstein wrote a suicide note indicating his planned death had nothing to do with Wells. She cried. In an earlier section of the video he says, "One of you guys said you found a liver in the garbage?" He was "a frugal person who saves scraps of sundry materials in order to reuse them in various projects." [11] Companies are diving to the bottom to scoop up metals essential for our EV-driven future. Officials believe he made the bomb using items in his home, as to not have to buy anything and leave a trail. That's where Wells was working at 1:30 pm on the day of the robbery, when an order came in for two small sausage-and-pepperoni pies to be delivered to a location on the outskirts of the city. This began with a visit to the ancient Buddhist caves of Ajanta, where he observed Lady Christiana Herringham and Nandalal Bose making watercolour copies of the ancient frescoes. From a seated position in front of a police car, Wells called out "It's going to go off, I'm not lying." he told them in desperation. WIRED tells the story of the strangest robbery ever, starting when a man walked into a bank with a bomb locked around his neck. During the 1890s Rothenstein exhibited with the New English Art Club and contributed drawings to The Yellow Book and The Savoy. He recruited coconspirators he knew he could control and kept crucial details of the plot from thema tactic designed to further complicate the investigation. The WIRED conversation illuminates how technology is changing every aspect of our livesfrom culture to business, science to design. Buchanan said the investigation has been complicated by the deaths of at least two witnesses. By Samantha Maffucci Written on May 17, 2018. ROTHSTEIN William A. Rothstein, 60, longtime Summit Township resident, Friday July 30, 2004. But if Diehl-Armstrong didn't set this plan in motion, who did? It's in the freezer., RELATED:Who Is Marjorie Diehl-Armstrong? Detectives who first interviewed him said that he spoke eloquently and took great pride in his mastery of the English language.. It was the FBI this time, calling to inform him that his pizza deliveryman was dead. In the frantic hours after Wells was killed, the cops tried completing the hunt themselves. After spending about 15 minutes at Rothstein's place, they took off. He told the cops that he had been in agony for weeks. "It's gonna go off!" Ad Choices, The Incredible True Story of the Collar Bomb Heist. Rothstein's house was near the TV tower. The woman who couldn't stop talking had already said far too much. In 1893 Rothenstein returned to Britain to work on "Oxford Characters" a series of lithographic portraits, eventually published in 1896[7] Other portrait collections by the artist include English Portraits (1898), Twelve Portraits (1929) and Contemporaries (1937). While he initially came into the investigation as a neighbor and former lover of Diehl-Armstrong, his involvement went much deeper, making us wonder, who is Bill Rothstein? Payback is a bitch, especially when it comes from an eccentric madman trying to prove his intellectual dominance. He had a short cane in his right hand and a strange bulge under the collar of his T-shirt. [1] In Oxford he met and became a close friend of the caricaturist and parodist Max Beerbohm, who later immortalised him in the short story Enoch Soames (1919). "The behavior seen in this crime was choreographed by 'Collarbomber' watching on the sidelines according to a written script in which he attempted to direct others to do what he wanted them to do Because of the complex nature of this crime, the [FBI's Behavioral Analysis Unit] believes there were multiple motives for the offender, and money was not the primary one." On February 10, 2006, federal agents met again with Diehl-Armstrong, who had brought her attorney. "There is only one way you can survive and that is to cooperate completely," the notes read in meticulous lettering that would later stymie handwriting analysis. At the conclusion of the drive, in which she admitted to being at several locations linked to the crime, Diehl-Armstrong told the agents she wouldn't provide any more information without receiving an immunity letter. Four years later, her husband, Richard Armstrong, died of a cerebral hemorrhage. He didn't get far. Rothstein was one of them. Investigators could tell that it had been built using professional tools. Wells was a loyal employeein 10 years, the only time he had called in late for work was when his cat died. Now comes the chilling coincidence; Bill Rothstein's house, with Roden's body in the garage, is located exactly next to the dirt road leading to the specific tower site that Brian Wells was sent to deliver the pizzas on August 28, 2003. He had considered killing himself, he told them, and had gone so far as to write a suicide note, which investigators found inside a desk at his home. At 2:28 pm on August 28, 2003, a middle-aged pizza deliveryman named Brian Wells walked into a PNC Bank in Erie, Pennsylvania. Police arrived and searched the property. WebOn September 20, 2003, Rothstein, who lived near the television tower, called police to inform them the body of a man, James Roden, was hidden in a freezer in a garage at his house. Moore was later to write that Rothenstein "gave me the feeling that there was no barrier, no limit to what a young provincial student could get to be and do". Kara Rhodes, Erie Times News reporter, was at the scene; "The bomb went off and there was just silence, it was eerily silent." He is buried in a plot the federal government purchased in Lot 1, Section 8G4F at South Granville Memorial Gardens in Butner, North Carolina, northwest of Raleigh. Undergraduate: College of William and Mary Hometown: Winchester, Virginia About me: Proud immigrant from Peru. It tells the story of a disintegrating marriage. Barnes confirmed the Feds' belief that Diehl-Armstrong was the mastermind behind the collar bomb plot. Wells' clothing added another layer of intrigue. New Details About The Woman From 'Evil Genius' On Netflix, Who Is Brian Wells? Officials believe he made the bomb using items in his home, as to not have to buy anything and leave a trail. Augustus John amusingly parodied the subject as if it were a typical Victorian painting that referred to him and to Alice as people and not as characters in the play: The painting was presented to the Tate Gallery by the artist's brother Charles Rutherston in 1924. It was a local matter and seemed to have nothing to do with their case. The police began sorting through a trove of physical evidence. Kate was born in 1870, and died October 6, 1926. He escaped punishment. I saw it on the news.". WebBill Rothstein leads investigators on a tour through his home at 8645 Peach St. and then through Marjorie Diehl-Armstrong's Seventh Street home, giving them details in regards to Jim Roden's death. Presented by Charles L. Rutherston 1917. It would have to come from her since I am a vegetarian and don't eat meat. Ross left in 1908, leaving the gallery in the hands of longtime financial manager Arthur Clifton. He left us with these idiots and a bunch of questions.". Wells entered the bank with this ingenious handmade gun disguised as a cane. Was it wise to let such an erratic, unpredictable personality testify? The latest on tech, science, and more: Get our newsletters! At the trial, information in this very tight-lipped case finally became available. To Fisher, that sounds like a description of Bill Rothstein, the man who lived next to the TV tower and who agreed to keep a dead man in his garage freezer. Webfrom Mary Sue & Beeler in FL March 1, 2018 for William C. House, MD. Stroud, Gloucestershire, 14 Feb. 1945). He takes time with you. Charles (18661927), who followed his father into the wool trade, was an important collector and left his entire collection to Manchester Art Gallery in 1925. from Peggy in FL February 28, 2018 for William C. House, MD. And, according to Fisher, there is no way that Marjorie Diehl-Armstrong planned the collar bomb caper. RELATED:8 Best True Crime Podcasts For People Who Just Love Being Scared. In the video, Rothstein exhibits the psychopathic behavior needed to be believable as the mastermind of this strange crime. He is awesome doctor! Once the officers noticed the collarbomb, they backed away from him and secured the area. The wind was blowing and his voice was cutting in and out. drawing stern warnings from the judge. Back in high school, according to former classmates, Diehl-Armstrong was known for her dazzling intelligence, and she still possessed an almost encyclopedic knowledge of literature, history, and the law. Slectionnez Grer les paramtres pour grer vos prfrences. It was only on the afternoon of the crime, when he delivered the pizzas to the TV transmission tower, that Wells realized he had been double-crossed and that the bomb was real. In 189899 he co-founded the Carfax Gallery (or Carfax & Co) in St. James' Piccadilly with John Fothergill (later innkeeper of the Spread Eagle in Thame). All rights reserved. Or was he? It seemed to be a risky move. The bomb was rigged such that any attempt to remove it would set it off. The hunt began at Mama Mia's Pizza-Ria. Informations sur votre appareil et sur votre connexion Internet, y compris votre adresseIP, Navigation et recherche lors de lutilisation des sites Web et applications Yahoo. This is a murder mystery/bank robbery that will satisfy the most tested sleuths. He felt comfortable sharing information as he claimed only to be providing a service to Diehl-Armstrong working as a "Cleaner" of her crime scene not unlike the character "Mr. Wolf" from the movie Pulp Fiction. Roden's body was found exactly where he said, in a freezer. He died wearing two T-shirts, the outer one emblazoned with a Guess clothing logo. [16][17], Rothenstein maintained a lifelong fascination for Indian sculpture and painting, and in 1910 set out on a seminal tour of the subcontinent's major artistic and religious sites. All the Settings You Should Change on Your New Samsung Phone, Fat, Sugar, Salt Youve Been Thinking About Food All Wrong, You Can Turn Your Backyard Into a Biodiversity Hot Spot, No, the James Webb Space Telescope Hasnt Broken Cosmology, The Out-of-Control Spread of Crowd-Control Tech. "At 8645 Peach Street, in the garage, there is a frozen body," he told the police dispatcher, referring to his own address. For seven years, the FBI was engaged in a scavenger hunt of its own, one that the Collar Bomber seemed to have planned as intricately as the one that had ensnared Wells. It contained drawings, threats, and detailed maps. Bombmaking materials were found in Rothstein's home. He takes time with you. He explained that she intended to put the body through a meat grinder and that he didn't think he could handle something like that. Barnes insisted he was kept in the dark about several aspects of the plot. The FBI believes a Stockton associate, William Rothstein, was the mastermind of the heist and likely made the bomb, the affidavit says. The bloody glob resting atop the garbage can was identified as a coagulated blood clot belonging to Bill Rothstein himself. She first drew public attention in 1984 when, at 35, she was charged with murdering her boyfriend, Robert Thomas. WebWilliam Rothenstein (18721945) (b Bradford, 29 Jan. 1872; d Far Oakridge, nr. The trip ended with a stay in Calcutta, where he witnessed the attempts of Abanindranath Tagore to revive the techniques and aesthetics of traditional Indian painting. He guided law enforcement agents through the filthy, garbage packed and rodent infested homes as if he was the teacher lecturing to students in forensic studies. Though he revealed the location of the body, he claimed he had no part in the murder of James Roden (who detectives later found out was, in fact, the frozen man and boyfriend of Marjorie Diehl-Armstrong), and had written a suicide note due to his guilt. For proof, Fisher points to a profile of the Collar Bomber produced by the FBI's Behavioral Analysis Unit. [20] Rothenstein was a master of lobbying and advocacy for his students, notably when, thanks to his efforts, Edward Bawden and Eric Ravilious were commissioned to paint a mural in the dining room of Morley College. Threatened with even more time behind bars, Barnes agreed to a deal: He would give a full account of the crime in exchange for a reduced sentence. Suddenly, the device started to emit an accelerating beeping noise. The crime scene footage takes place at two addresses in Erie, Diehl-Armstrong's home on Bacon St. (where Roden was shot and killed) and Rothstein's home on Peach St. (where the body was kept). Which lets you explain your symptoms before he hive you his opinion. For 25 minutes Wells remained seated on the pavement, his legs curled beneath him. Diehl-Armstrong claimed she shot him six times in self-defense, and a jury eventually acquitted her. WebWilliam Rothenstein (18721945) (b Bradford, 29 Jan. 1872; d Far Oakridge, nr. Around 4:00pm that same afternoon Tony received a different type of call. Sir William Rothenstein was an influential English critic and artist, known for his lithographic portraits, such as those in Oxford Characters (1893), and his paintings, a number of whch are held at the Tate. Police hate coincidences, he knew that. The contraption was a puzzle in and of itself. The indictment also charged that other conspirators were involved. She also seemed to be the kind of person who would likely be unable to stop herself from telling the world about her brilliant ruse. [9], In 1900 Rothenstein won a silver medal for his painting The Doll's House at the Exposition Universelle. [1], He married Alice Knewstub in 1899[1] with whom he had four children: John, Betty, Rachel and Michael. After all, why would someone who was involved in the plot voluntarily call the cops and meet with them for hours? Several times she blurted out "Liar!" The news report on TV that evening showed Wells walk into the PNC Bank branch in the Summit Town Plaza and rob it using a live bomb. 2023 BuzzFeed, Inc. All rights reserved. "There isn't a place I'd rather be. She also said that Wells, the dead pizza delivery guy, was not just a victim but had been in on the plan. Even though he was at the end of his shift, he agreed to deliver the order. And could Diehl-Armstrong, with her myriad mental issues, really plan such a complex crime? But over the years, that brilliance had become spiked with madness. In her free time, you can find her obsessing about cats, wine, and all things Vanderpump Rules. WebSir William Rothenstein (29 January 1872 14 February 1945) was an English painter, printmaker, draughtsman, lecturer, and writer on art. But the plan may threaten the fragile landscapeand a tenacious billionaires ambitions. That notion was what pushed him to call police. The two dated on and off in the 1960s and 70s. He is buried in a plot the federal government purchased in Lot 1, Section 8G4F at South Granville Memorial Gardens in Butner, North Carolina, northwest of Raleigh. Prosecutors opted to press on, and the trial was rescheduled for October 12. The bomb itself was likewise a marvel of DIY design and construction. Police at the scene found eight pages of notes directing Wells on a scavenger hunt of sorts in search of keys to unlock the bomb from around his neck. The impact caused a contusion to his chest and stoppage of his heart. The dirt road leading there was cordoned off by authorities, but the journalists spotted a tall, heavyset man in denim Carhartt overalls pacing in front of a home that sat right next to it. He kept James Rodens corpse in a chest freezer in his garage for five weeks. He had agreed to rob the bank wearing what he thought was a fake bomb. Once the FBI inferred Wells as a participant, his days were gone as a tragic figure. She yelled. Dr. Rothstein is a professor of theory/analysis at Queens College and the Graduate Center. WebWilliam Rothenstein (18721945) (b Bradford, 29 Jan. 1872; d Far Oakridge, nr. the house to retrieve a letter he wrote exposing Nora, which will be found by Helmer at the end of the dance. Rothstein continued to deny any knowledge of the collar bomb plot on his deathbed, even though he seemingly had no more reason to hide. Brother of Jon Rothstein, Sr. and wife Linda Ann, Erie and Paulette Rothstein, Muskegon, MI. The fake bomb turned out to be a real one. He approaches a garbage can in his kitchen. The swan song of a deranged, eccentric, and highly intelligent mastermind who never succeeded at anything in life. The next day, a reporter and a photographer for the Erie Times-News headed to the tower. Wells was a loyal employeein 10 years, the only time he had called in late for work was when his cat died. John is wearing a coat and a pair of corduroy peg-top trousers which were made In addition to his book, PHRASE RHYTHM IN TONAL MUSIC, which received an ASCAP-Deems Taylor Award and the Society for Music Theory's Young Scholar Award, Dr. Rothstein has published numerous articles. Rothstein, 59, was an unmarried handyman and a lifelong resident of the area. They headed into the thick brush but still couldn't see much. "This powerful, booby-trapped bomb can be removed only by following our instructions ACT NOW, THINK LATER OR YOU WILL DIE!" Diehl-Armstrong said she wouldn't say more without receiving immunity. None of this, Fisher says, sounds much like Diehl-Armstrong, who prosecutors credited with planning the whole affair in order to get enough money to pay a hit man. Stroud, Gloucestershire, 14 Feb. 1945). He could have asked me for money, he could have asked his brother John for money. [3] Both brothers changed their surname to Rutherston during the First World War. He had two sisters, Addie, born February 19, 1878, and Jerusha (Ziegler) who also lived in Titusville. WebWilliam married Kate Reed in 1890 at Titusville, Florida. I'm sick and not sure how much longer I will live." Son of the late Matthias and B. Virginia Bryner Rothstein. He retrieved a two-page note from the flower bed, which directed him up Peach Street to a wooded area several miles away, where a container with orange tape would hold the next set of instructions. [8], Another feature of this period are the celebrated interiors he painted, the most famous of which is The Browning Readers (1900), now owned by Cartwright Hall gallery, Bradford. New Details About The Woman From 'Evil Genius' On Netflix. Her wavy black hair looked greasy and clung to the sides of her face. First a federal judge ruled Diehl-Armstrong mentally unfit to stand trial. The Matrix movies brought Reeves and Chad Stahelski together. Brain injuries. But by that time, Rothstein was past caring about the old girlfriend he'd given up to the cops: He had died of lymphoma in July 2004. [2] Albert (18811953) was a painter, illustrator and costume designer. In an affidavit, another co-conspirator, Floyd Stockton, claimed he carried the bomb out of Rothsteins garage on the day of the robbery. [21] After being appointed, he introduced greater informality and was permitted to appoint practising artists, including Paul Nash and Edward Johnston as visiting lecturers. Dr. Rothstein is a professor of theory/analysis at Queens College and the Graduate Center. He got to know of Ibsen's work through Conder, and he was later introduced by George Bernard Shaw to the actress Janet That he was a part of it. Stroud, Gloucestershire, 14 Feb. 1945). The news was shocking. During the 1930s he published three volumes of memoirs: Men and Memories, Vol I and II and Since Fifty. "The son of a bitch ended up winning," Fisher says. Contributors control their own work and posted freely to our site. Not inscribed. When the Feds met with Diehl-Armstrong, she told them that, if they could arrange a transfer from Muncy state penitentiary to the minimum-security prison in Cambridge Springs, a facility much closer to Erie, she would tell them everything she knew. He stood waiting in line for the teller, and then handed her a cryptic note demanding $250,000.00. Rocket-obsessed oligarchs. The painting's title refers to Ibsen's 1879 play A Doll's House, which had its first London performance in 1889.